Go Ask Alice

With two new releases, Tom Waits travels ever farther down the rabbit hole of his imagination -- and our American past

Americans make dismal historians. Most of us can't name our own great-grandparents, much less offer a coherent explanation for the War of 1812 or the decline of the Roman Empire.

Perversely, this amnesiac regard for the past has become a manifestation of our national pride. Unlike, say, England -- a country still wringing money from druids, for God's sake -- the United States has little in the way of historical monuments. And why should we? Americans rode to the moon via progress and technical innovation, not some sentimental adherence to the tried and true. We are a nation of transplants, a country of iconoclasts, and though we spill our share of milk, we spend very little time crying over it.

Inevitably, though, all this future boosterism becomes both tiring and terribly unromantic. There's only so long you can fly headlong into the promise of tomorrow before you start getting a little curious about the stuff that's already sailed past.

For college students, this hazy nostalgia expresses itself principally through thrift store clothes and the occasional Robert Doisneau poster of post-World War II Paris. Thirtysomethings tend to take their personal archaeology a step further, tackling jazz, religion, and the age-old mysteries of childbirth all within the same 10 years. Fortysomethings start buying antiques and sports cars. And hipsters of all ages discover Tom Waits.

1983's groundbreaking Swordfishtrombones album -- in which he abandoned his singer/songwriter balladry and proto-lounge warble for something darker and more theatrical -- turned Waits into alternative music's Ancient One. He's now known as a wild-haired soothsayer able to slip through the portals of time and return, sooty and raving, with haunted stories of a lost industrial age. His voice -- gruff as a mule-team driver and as old as God -- hearkens back to a time of bellowing accordions, shadowy wharves, and dangerous, limitless possibility. For busy bohemians, putting on a record like Waits' Franks Wild Years is an easy way to bathe in the romance of an enchanted and unsettling past, without actually having to contend with a tiresome array of footnotes and source materials.

This week, the historically challenged hit pay dirt, as Anti-Records releases two new atmospheric excavations from Waits and his longtime collaborator (and wife), Kathleen Brennan: the superlative Aliceand the less alluring but worthwhile Blood Money.

Composed over a six-week period in 1992, the songs on Alice formed the backbone of a Robert Wilson-directed musical exploring the relationship between Charles Dodgson (aka Lewis Carroll) and Alice Liddell, the young girl who inspired Alice's Adventures in Wonderlandand Through the Looking-Glass. The musical (the second in a trilogy of Waits/Wilson collaborations that began with The Black Rider) ran for 18 months at Hamburg's Thalia Theater in the early '90s, but Waits didn't get around to recording the songs until last summer.

The wait was worth it. Alice is, in short, a revelation. The 15 songs, a hodgepodge of accordion- and piano-flush ballads and Waits' trademark graveyard jump-jazz, form his most tender work since 1977's Foreign Affairs.

The record opens with the titular tune, in which Waits' lead character, Dodgson, sounds like one of the hopeless barflies who populated his early albums. Trying in vain to exorcise the memories of a long-gone love, Dodgson sings a drunken dedication as smooth as the now-frozen pond where he and Alice spent their summers together: "I must be insane to go skating on your name/ By tracing it twice/ I fell through the ice of Alice."

Most of Alice unfolds through Dodgson's laments about his beloved, many of them sung in the stricken, disbelieving voice of an admirer forced to watch the object of his affection go on without him. "From a window across the lawn I watched you undress/ Moving in a yellow bedroom light," he confesses in "Watch Her Disappear."

Waits has always had a knack for poetry, but the story of a shy mathematician and his pre-adolescent muse seems to have stirred the songwriter to new heights. The lyrics on rough-hewn ballads like "Lost in the Harbour" and "Barcarolle" -- which contain the unforgettable images of waterlogged sheep in icy seas and a ghost wrapped, contented and warm, around a dollar in a young girl's pocket -- unfold with a deliberate, surprising beauty, like priceless treasures being pulled from a castaway wooden crate.

Of course it wouldn't be a Tom Waits album without a couple of braying freaks. Without explanation, we get to meet Poor Edward, a man with a woman's face ruinously attached to the back of his head, and Table Top Joe, a Coney Island sideshow curiosity who takes the music world by storm despite his lack of torso (the latter song featuring an unlikely cameo from Stewart Copeland of the Police on drums).

Apart from these occasional swerves under the circus tent and a few Black Rider-esque primeval tangos -- of which the guttural scat number "Kommienezuspadt" is especially delightful -- the songs on Alice are mostly of an introspective sort. This superb balance of hot summer emotion and autumnal regret is what separates the disc from Blood Money, the other of Waits' works being released this week.

Next Page »
My Voice Nation Help
San Francisco Concert Tickets

Concert Calendar

  • July
  • Wed
  • Thu
  • Fri
  • Sat
  • Sun
  • Mon
  • Tue
©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.