Death, Maiming, Money, and Muni

Muni's continuing refusal to face and deal with a safety problem that kills citizens and costs taxpayers millions seems to be based, like many a chronic San Francisco problem, in bureaucratic inertia and union politics. Over the years, Muni has allowed its standards for hiring and disciplining drivers to be set out in its contracts with TWU Local 250A. Because overtime increases drivers' pay, there is little incentive for the politically influential TWU to call for reforms to reduce overtime, and, thereby, the driver fatigue at the root of many transit accidents. In essence, transit safety has been a bargaining chip in contract talks, rather than a focus of concern -- for either union leaders or Muni management.

It's a chip, apparently, that will remain part of the game.

Jack Gescheidt

Andy Gescheidt was struck in the head by a trolley pole.

Jack Gescheidt

Gescheidt nearly died.

Related Content

• Pilots Say Flying United Airlines Isn't That Safe
  May 4, 2012
• S.F. Ferry Ticketers to Strike Today to Protest Automation
  July 1, 2011
• The Cup Runneth Over: S.F.'s America's Cup Decision Looms
  February 15, 2012
• Broke Caltrain Moves to Cut Half its Service
  April 2, 2010
• Happy Girl Kitchen and B. Patisserie Co-Host a Pop-Up
  April 19, 2012

More About

• Sarah Benton
• Passenger Transportation
• Mass Transit Systems
• Transportation
• Public Transportation

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Weekly Newsletter: Our weekly feature stories, movie reviews, calendar picks and more - minus the newsprint and sent directly to your inbox.

Privacy Policy Cancel Continue

"Whether or not it makes sense to include safety and discipline issues in collective bargaining negotiations is not the issue," Burns says. "Ideally, you would prefer not to. But it's a long-standing tradition in San Francisco to do so.

"It's not going to change. It's the character of the system."