Burnt Chefs

Former admissions representatives at CCA say they preyed on students’ dreams of becoming celebrity chefs and glossed over the painful economic realities of the industry

Next to the posters in CCA's bright and modern admissions office, there's a flat-screen TV that's perpetually tuned to the Food Network. Around lunchtime, there's the Barefoot Contessa. A few hours later, along comes Emeril.

The sheen of celebrity that clings to chefs these days is one of the best things CCA has going for it. People with dreams of prime time flock to CCA's admissions office, where the school's representatives know just what to do.

The school brags about its alumnus Chris Kronner; he doesn't return the favor.
Paolo Vescia
The school brags about its alumnus Chris Kronner; he doesn't return the favor.
Students leave CCA's new building on Potrero Hill.
Paolo Vescia
Students leave CCA's new building on Potrero Hill.

Related Content

More About

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Dining Newsletter: The week's top local food news and events, plus interviews with chefs and restaurant owners, dining tips, and a peek at our print review.

Privacy Policy

"They sell them this dream that they're going to have their own cooking show," says a woman who used to work as an admissions counselor, whom we'll call Emily. She asked to remain anonymous because she now works for a competing school. In 2004 she quit her CCA job and sent a whistle-blowing letter to the state regulatory agency. "You tell them, "We have this graduate who has a TV show ... and this graduate who has a show.' That's how you sell it," Emily says.

To channel leads to the admissions office, the school engages in a marketing campaign that includes ads on daytime TV, when people who are trying to figure out their lives are likely to be flipping through the channels. CCA also sends representatives out to speak at high schools, to recruit fresh-faced seniors who aren't interested in college, but have no idea what else to do. On the Web site, prospective students can fill out a survey to determine if they're a "candidate for acceptance," which channels them straight into an online enrollment process.

Jennifer D'Ambrosio also saw it all from the inside. She worked as an admissions rep in San Francisco for five months in 2004, after transferring from a Los Angeles school also owned by parent company Career Education Corporation.

D'Ambrosio says the CCA admissions office was a pressure cooker, and that the admissions representatives would go to whatever lengths necessary to meet their numbers — each rep needed 15 enrollments per month to stay in the administration's good graces. Both D'Ambrosio and Emily said that representatives believed that they would be fired if they didn't hit their numbers for a few months in a row, and they were rewarded if they did. Emily recalled getting a free dinner at the Ritz-Carlton and gift certificates to the school store for hitting her enrollment numbers. Under federal law, it's illegal for schools to pay recruiters based on the number of students they enroll, but CCA could be skirting that line.

In CCA President Gibson's written response, she denied that the school compensates its reps based on the number of enrollments, but said that their bonus policy is based on student retention and graduation rates. She wrote that she could not speculate on the circumstances surrounding the specific allegations being made, but that admissions reps were expected to deal with students with honesty and integrity.

But both former employees say they worked at CCA at a difficult time for the institution — the school had just started a new program in hospitality and restaurant management, and was trying to expand into a new building on Potrero Hill. The admissions staff apparently wasn't roping in enough students to fill those classes. During the year Emily worked there, the number of admissions reps doubled, from about 15 to more than 30. Today, there are 37 admissions reps listed on the office roster.

To close a sale, admissions reps engaged in tactics worthy of a used-car dealership, the two insiders say. Both women say the administrators were obsessed with meeting the numbers for the next start date, and admissions reps were told to pressure students who wanted to delay enrollment to start as soon as possible. They always told students that classes were filling up fast. And when the school didn't have enough students signing up for the management program, Emily alleges that her supervisor in admissions told reps to steer all their applicants to that program — by whatever means necessary. "Every student you interview today is going to hospitality and restaurant management," Emily claims her supervisor said. "Tell them that's the most marketable degree."

Finally, the admissions counselors tried to make the program seem worth its exorbitant price tag by giving students the impression that the school was selective. "We were advised to tell the students that because it's such a prestigious school, Cordon Bleu recognized, yadda yadda, you have to tell me why you should be accepted," D'Ambrosio says.

The two women claim that actually, anyone with a high school diploma who could get a loan was in. At the Los Angeles school that D'Ambrosio worked at prior to CCA, she says the admissions reps joked that all a prospective student needed for admission was the $50 application fee and a pulse. At CCA, the situation was a little different: "The admission fee was more than $50 — but you still just needed a pulse." Emily adds, "They were enrolling people who don't speak English, who tell you they have a very serious learning disability. It's like, 'Yeah, uh-huh, can you sign up for a loan? Then you're going to school.'"


The CCA graduates who now feel the most ripped-off have one thing in common: They went in to CCA with a strong desire to better themselves, and to rise in the world, but came out weighed down instead.

<< Previous Page | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next Page >>
 
  • Austincgeorge 01/03/2012 9:31:00 AM

    Shut up and get back to work, you idiots. 14 hour days are the jam in this donut so get with it. Time to lean time to clean. Do it nice or do it twice. The customer could give a shit about your problems so show up on time and get the food out with a smile on your face. You are in the service industry. That means you are a servant. Get it? Probably not which is why I'll cook circles around you until you cry in the parking lot.

  • 10/05/2011 7:20:00 PM

    I went to CCA for the Hospitality Management program; one missed class project gave me an F in one of the courses, which disqualified me from getting placed in an externship by CCA. So I left without finishing the program. It was just a waste of time and money - and would have been even if I had finished. I had no idea one missed project would, ironically, not allow me to represent CCA in the most flattering light.

  • Siralize808 10/04/2011 10:51:00 PM

    Very true Tyler

  • Siralize808 10/04/2011 10:50:00 PM

    True. But even if your on the top of your class and get all you can out of school. The amount you learn is still NOT worth $40-$60,000. Your better off saving up money and getting on the job training. Because in 2-3 years you will have more money in your pocket and most likely be at the same level or higher than that person who went to culonary school. Find a chef that your admire try to get a entry level positions and work your way. because in 1-2 years of working on the job your will be more experienced/prepared for the REAL kitchens. You should work atleast 1 year in a kitchen then see if you want to go to culinary school. And even then your probally 85% going to learn more on the job!

  • Siralize808 10/04/2011 10:42:00 PM

    SO TRUE!!

  • Tyler 09/17/2011 4:38:00 AM

    Vicki must have not noticed that this article was posted in 2007...4 years prior to her reply. After all the bad publicity CCA has gotten on the web, obviously a few things are gonna be changed to make their image look better, but I don't doubt that they are still practicing unethical business practices.

  • trapeze 05/04/2011 9:11:00 AM

    I attended the California Culinary Academy in 2009, I had been working for months to secure my externship abroad, when they told me that since I was a minor (I started college early) they couldn't allow me to do an international externship. 2 weeks before my externship started. I already had my tickets bought, my passport, an apartment rented, paperwork filled out so I could work in Europe, everything. I couldn't find an externship on time, and they wanted me to pay for an extra semester of classes or take medical leave. Once I graduated, I started looking for a job, I went into the career center and asked for help. I was told since I was only 17, they couldn't help me find work, and I should try nannying. I didn't pay $28,000 to be a nanny. Once I did convince them to help me find work, they constantly referred me to monster or snagajob. So much for a career center, I did all the work myself. They advertise that you'll be making about $45,000 a year, more for higher up chefs, that the employment rate of students is extremely high. In reality, you get $10/hour, and that's if you can find a job. A lot of the jobs the school posts are temporary or seasonal positions.

  • vicki 05/03/2011 5:13:00 AM

    I am a current student at CCA and I must say that this article has one sided subjective point of view and it does not reflect the totality of what CCA represents today. I have never been told that I was going to become famous or that I was going to have a promising job after I completed my program. I'm actually reminded almost everyday that if I was to start off in a kitchen as a prep cook or line cook I will be getting paid $10-$12 an hour. Right now I'm learning that I will get paid even less because we're in the course where we calculate state taxes. But anyway... When I decided to enroll myself into this school I knew from day one that whatever goals I wanted to achieve were going to take hard work and I was definitely not going to be handed a one way ticket to a fine restaurant after I graduated. Yes, after a few months I got the feeling that the school was a bit money hungry based on observing my surroundings and facing a lot of changes. I could view CCA as a fat pig that loves money and doesn't care about it's students but that isn't true and I am honestly sick and tired of hearing such negative feedback about CCA. Every educational establishment has its pros and cons. It's completely normal. At CCA us students are given the basic skills and knowledge and it is up to us on how we want to utilize them. I appreciate every one of my instructors because they care about each and every one of us. I view majority of them as my mentors. I don't want anyone to look down on CCA as if it's lost its integrity because it hasn't. I'm proud to be a CCA student and I look forward to being an alumni regardless of everything CCA is going through or what anyone has to say. After interning at two fine restaurant to gain some confidence in a restaurant kitchen, I thought maybe I'm not cut out to be a chef- the hours, pressure, labor, etc. can be a overwhelming and exhausting. I realized I didn't want to be the one capable of getting fired but the one firing. I love this industry and I will do everything I can to find my niche. I know I will. If not? Life goes on and I am going to keep moving forward.

  • Billm100 01/29/2011 3:34:00 PM

    Wow, how sad to hear the CCA is now like this. As Chef Rick below me posted, I went there in 1990/91 and it was a fantastic school with outstanding Chef instructors. There were no promises made back then other than, we promise it will take lots of hard work and dedication after you graduate to work your way up to being a Chef. Certainly no promises of $45K a year jobs just waiting to sign you up. I also remember many students getting less than stellar marks and not getting free passes just for being a warm body.

  • Chef Rick Manning 01/25/2011 12:35:00 AM

    To all up and coming Chef's. The C.C.A. was once the finest school on the west coast! I was lucky enough to attend and graduate in 88-89! I had been in the food service business for 15 years before I enrolled in school. It was like somebody opened the flood gates and I was hit with a wealth of knowledge and I soaked it up like a sponge! The thing that I remember the most about our admission office at the time is that , they had an article framed and hanging on the wall in the waiting area with a caption You may be a graduate, but that doesn't make you a Chef.The article went on to explain that you have to work hard and apply what you had learned to move up the ladder to becoming an Executive Chef. It also stated that it would take 5-10 years for the average person to acquire this level of knowledge and advancement. We were taught this by every Chef there, here are the tools and knowledge, now go out and use them! I took that article and the Chefs advice, and did exactly that! I took a line cook job in Lake Tahoe and was soon promoted to a Restaurant Manager"I had previous experience" but soon realized how much I missed the kitchen! I took a dinner cooks job at a local resort that only served breakfast and lunch, we installed a dinner menu and thrived there for a year being able to run my own menu and specials! I was called out front one night and was introduced to the Executive Chef of the new Planet Hollywood that was being built! He enjoyed my special that night and asked if I would be interested in working into a Sous Chefs position with them! Of course I jumped on the opportunity and worked in the Tahoe unit for 3 months and went to the new Reno unit where I became a Sous Chef and worked a couple of years there! I saw an add in the local paper in Tahoe for an Executive Chef position at Sequoia-Kings Canyon National Parks, it required multi-unit experience which I had attained as a Restaurant Manager, I was hired and took over a department that had an 89% food cost across both parks! I shopped purveyors and made some changes, I also put the first Fine Dining Restaurant in the Grant Grove location, when I left to take a job in Alaska, I left them with a 28.9% food cost! I took a job on Kodiak Island and now work for a high end fishing and hunting camp in a very lucrative job.I cook breakfast and dinner for up to 40 guests and I specialize in fresh Alaskan seafood and game! I work June-mid December and have the rest of my time to travel! To this day I thank my lucky stars that I was able to learn from some of the best Chefs teaching at the time. Thank You Chef Leo Kholler, Master Chef Michael Reich, Lars Kromack, Desmond Diedier, Jean Marc Fulsack, Jean Luc and Chef Bo who was the only one not to give me an A in his class! Like I said the C.C.A. was a great school till it changed hands! I suggest anyone that is serious and has a passion for the Culinary Arts, go check out Greystone in Napa, its run by the C.I.A.Culinary Institute Of America or I saw a new French Cooking school in New York owned and run by the French! French Culinary Institute! Study hard, work hard and success will come your way! With All Respect Chef Richard Manning C.E.C.

 
Browse Voice Nation
  • Voice Places

    Voice Places

    Discover restaurants, nightlife, travel, shopping...

  • VOICE Daily Deals

    VOICE Daily Deals

    Get 50 to 90% off every day on restaurants, movies, massages...

  • Best Of

    Best Of...

    More than 10,000 of the BEST things to eat, drink, and experience

  • My Voice Nation

    My Voice Nation

    Join the Village Voice community and get exclusive deals and info

  • Happy Hour

    Happy Hour

    Your local Happy Hour guide at your fingertips

or

Log in or Sign up

Social Connect:

Use your favorite account to access My Voice Nation.


Use your My Voice Nation account to log in:





Forgot password?
or

Sign Up or Log in

Social Connect:

Sign up for My Voice Nation with your preferred network.


Sign up for a My Voice Nation account:



Privacy policy