Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

Nothing in Common 

To right-wingers, all rap is the same. It's not.

Wednesday, Aug 29 2007
Comments

In his continuing crusade against hip hop, FOX News polemicist Bill O'Reilly recently went on the attack against N.Y.C. rapper Nas. He tagged the Queensbridge MC a "gangster rapper," and claimed that by performing at a benefit for Virginia Tech victims, Nas was "insulting the murder victims." Affecting moral outrage, the paunchy conservative blowhard trotted out an old gun charge against the rapper and cited a few out-of-context lyrics such as the chorus to "Got Yourself a Gun" that samples the Sopranos theme song, making us wonder if O'Reilly is going to badger James Gandolfini the next time he does something for charity. Understanding that the noisome provisions of free speech protect artists such as Nas, O'Reilly next took aim at those who enable the First Amendment, dubbing Dr. Charles Steiger, the Virginia Tech president, a "coward" and demanding that he immediately be fired.

Of course, O'Reilly conveniently overlooks the fact that Nas' lyrics track the full arch of violence, chronicling everything from the initial sparks of aggression to the bullet's trajectory before zooming out to examine how the outlying lives, homes, and communities are subsequently affected.

It's doubtful that O'Reilly, his millions of listeners and viewers, and the legions of wannabes that infect our airwaves have ever taken the time to actually listen to rap lyrics. If they had, they'd notice a complex dialogue on issues of race, violence, and class. Nowhere is this important conversation more evident than in the music of Common.

The Chicago MC got his start more than a decade ago. In his early lyrics, he championed a transformation in hip hop from the bling and gun blast of Bay Boy/Death Row-era hip hop to a more morally tenable and socially conscious mutation of the art. And while Common still gives lip service to the ideas and ideals of the mid-'90s boho set on his new album, Finding Forever, those songs are the weakest of the set. On "The People," for example, Common sounds trite and noncommittal as he champions the unspecified masses who hunger for freedom, truth, and Obama.

But as with most who speak of the nobility of "the people," when Common takes a closer look at individual lives, he's far more cynical. The two main characters in "Drivin' Me Wild" (a delectable bit of post-Gorillaz electro anchored by Lily Allen's effervescent hook) are driven by their impulses and delusions. The beautiful "Misunderstood," meanwhile, captures a typically smoky Nina Simone snippet between the production's sweeping, melancholic soul, and features the rapper tracking the spiritual disillusionment of a hustler and a stripper.

What's wonderful about these songs is that Common is able to link the public and the private — the songs' characters have problems that speak to the larger struggle, enabling Common to comment on social problems without seeming didactic. The songs' inhabitants search for meaning, but more often than not find that their dreams lead them astray.

Of course, the ultimate fallen dream for black America is the idea of equality, and Common eloquently speaks on that in the excellent "U Black, Maybe." He claims that "a white man's yes is a black man's maybe," but unlike in previous generations, the enemy is as likely to wear a BAPE hoodie as a KKK hood. He illustrates this by chronicling the rise and fall of a basketball player who is gunned down by jealous friends, and concludes the song with a spoken-word outro stating, "We talk about situations of people of color, and because you are that color, you endure obstacles and opposition, and not all the time from other nationalities, sometimes it comes from your kind, or maybe even your own mind."

It's doubtful that any of Finding Forever's insight would change the right's estimation of hip hop. Subtlety, complexity, and context are lost when you're waging a race war. And, for those who traffic in fear and innuendo, thoughtful rappers such as Common and Nas are just angry black men talking up guns, hos, and bitches. These conservative pundits aren't attacking obscenity in hip hop, they're targeting hip hop. Take nothing for granted.

About The Author

Sam Chennault

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Slideshows

  • Cirque du Soleil Returns to San Francisco
    Cirque du Soleil returns to AT&T park with their current production Kurious: Cabinet of Curiosities. Photographs by Richard Haick.
  • Slayer @ Fox Theater
    Slayer, Exodus and Suicidal Tendencies performed at the Fox Theater in Oakland on November 12, 2014. Photographs by Richard Haick.

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed