Most Popular

National Features >

  • Westword

    Fuel's Gold

    How William Orr's quest for better, cheaper gas became a crime.

    By Alan Prendergast

  • Miami New Times

    Mold Over Miami

    The family of a dead judge blames a creeping fungus in the federal courthouse.

    By Tim Elfrink

  • The Pitch

    McCain Girl

    I worked at Kmart with John McCain's director of strategy.

    By Alan Scherstuhl

Blogos-Free

Continued from page 1

Published on December 05, 2007

I'd first run across Gray's apparent plagiarism while searching for information on a secretive nonprofit foundation that pays for Governor Schwarzenegger to fly on junkets around the world. It turned out Gray had pasted most of a Sacramento Bee story on the nonprofit into what seemed to be her own work.

"I knew not to put that up there," she said. "I knew I shouldn't. I obviously did something not professional. I was not trying to do anything wrong.

"I was just passionately trying to draw attention to something that was obviously bad for the people of California," she added, in reference to the secretive funding of Schwarzenegger's trips.

The Bee's Shane Goldmacher, who wrote the original junket story, said, "The Bee has a strict policy for attributing information, and we hope other newspapers would do the same."

Gray didn't just borrow unattributed from the Bee. In her blog's pre-Thursday incarnation, she had constructed pieces about Larry Ellison's yacht team, the San Francisco Bay bird rescue and cleanup, and other topical issues by pasting together paragraphs from other sources.

However, I don't believe she should be burned at the stake for this apparent misstep. A little bit of training and editing assistance for Gray, a self-described elderly woman who says she's hoping to relaunch a writing career, could have gone a long way.

She seems to have failed to distinguish between the common and legitimate blogging tactic of aggregating, citing, summarizing, and linking to news stories, and the illegitimate practice of pasting together news stories from various sources and posting them under her own name. And I doubt she'll do this again.

Rather than becoming a pariah among journalists, I think Gray should be held up as a bit of a hero for potentially rattling the nerves of newspapers, Web startups, and other aspiring online media feudal lords. By betting their bottom line on getting people to work unsupervised for free, companies might get no better than what they paid for.

« Previous Page   1   2

SF Weekly Insiders

  • Local food, music and news blasts
  • Free Stuff
Backpage.com