More Like Plus One Million

Scott McCaughey is unsung. He's in four major bands — R.E.M., the Young Fresh Fellows, Robyn Hitchcock's backing band the Venus 3, and the Minus 5 — plus a gang of semi-bands like K.M.R.I.A. (Kiss My Royal Irish Ass), a Pogues cover group that only plays on St. Patrick's Day and Christmas. Currently, he's on tour with three bands (one of which has written an entire album about baseball), all of which are made up of the same three other people. Our favorite of the three bands, since it's the only one we've heard, is the Minus 5. This particular McCaughey getup is a rangy, mercurial thing featuring a rotating cast of shockingly talented players (like, say, Wilco) but almost always containing Peter Buck. It sounds like the New Pornographers crashing into either the Replacements or the Flying Burrito Brothers, depending on the song; a new, not-baseball-themed record, Killingsworth, has pedal steel guitar on every track. "Your wedding day was so well planned," coos McCaughey, "like a German occupation." And yet he's not a household name.

Related Content

• Sizzle & Fizzle: Highs and Lows from the Last Week in S.F. Music
  February 1, 2012
• Wilco's The Whole Love: A First Listen
  September 23, 2011
• Live Review, 1/29/12: Wilco Airs a Gorgeous Melancholy at the Warfield
  January 30, 2012
• The Wizard of Wilco: A Conversation with Guitarist Nels Cline
  January 25, 2012
• Robyn Hitchcock Brings the Quietly Penetrating Eye Back to the City Where He Made It
  November 18, 2011

More About

• Scott McCaughey
• Peter Buck
• Robyn Hitchcock
• St. Patrick's Day
• Weddings

Like this Story?

Sign up for the Events Newsletter: What's happening in town? From underground club nights to the biggest outdoor festivals, our top picks for the week's best events will always keep you in on the action.

Privacy Policy Cancel Continue

Steve Wynn IV and the Baseball Project open.
Sun., Aug. 30, 8 p.m., 2009