Pin It

Muni Fail 

Federal scrutiny could threaten funding for the Central Subway boondoggle.

Wednesday, Mar 3 2010

Last month, Mayor Gavin Newsom and a dozen bureaucrats, politicians, and other notables grasped gold-painted spades, then simultaneously lifted them and lowered them into the ground as if they were the shoveling equivalent of the Rockettes. They were celebrating the supposed launch of a 1.7-mile, $1.6 billion rail line called the Central Subway, designed to connect SOMA and Chinatown.

But a recent letter from a top Obama administration transportation official obtained by SF Weekly suggests to critics that the ground-breaking ceremony may have been premature. In order for Muni to obtain $942 million in federal funding essential to the project's completion, the Federal Transportation Administration has demanded that San Francisco prove it can come up with an extra $164 million in local and state funds, and — harder still — prove that the subway won't screw up the rest of San Francisco's bus and light-rail network.

The letter orders Muni to prove it will keep the rest of its system shipshape, even as it adds a new subway line with its own maintenance and management costs, slashes millions of dollars from its operating budget, and deploys service cuts sure to depress fare-paying ridership.

David Schonbrunn, a longtime Sausalito-based activist who has sued several area transit agencies based on allegations that projects were wasteful, said the Jan. 7 letter from FTA regional administrator Leslie Rogers to Muni chief Nat Ford was unusually strong.

"I thought it was amazing," Schonbrunn said. "You don't usually see that kind of backbone. We're talking about a project where the speaker of the House of Representatives could possibly have an opinion, and where two senators have an opinion. Ordinarily, that tends to create tremendous inhibition on the part of agencies."

The Central Subway was conceived less as an actual transportation solution than as a sop to long-ago mayoral candidate Willie Brown's Chinatown political supporters. Nancy Pelosi has championed the project, which has so far secured $72 million in federal transit funding. At the end of 2009, the city had spent $51.4 million on design and other Central Subway expenses.

Oakland civil engineer Gerald Cauthen, a former deputy director of the Transbay Joint Powers Authority who was the chief engineer for San Francisco's Muni Transit Improvement Program during the 1980s, said the requirements could threaten the project.

"Muni's in dire straits already," said Cauthen, long an outspoken Central Subway opponent. "Adding this subway operation won't save money. It will incur millions of dollars in additional operating and maintenance costs."

John Funghi, the Central Subway program manager who helped with the ground-breaking event, counters that Rogers' letter is nothing out of the ordinary.

"I don't believe the FTA has an issue with the operating expenses when that comes online," he said. "It's been proven that the Central Subway will enhance the operating capacity and financial picture of the agency."

Funghi said Muni has already calculated the transit system's overall costs, and that "the financial picture with Central Subway in the picture is a bright one. In fact, it will reduce the operating needs of the program, and it will reduce the per-passenger cost for the overall agency."

He may well be right. Perhaps Muni will prove it can remain fiscally sound once the new subway is built. The FTA may merely be going through the motions in advance of sending a project nearly $1 billion in funding, money critics say could be more efficiently spent elsewhere. Obama administration bureaucrats may be playing the role of tough guys, even though the money will eventually come through.

However, the recent demise of the planned Oakland Airport Connector from BART indicates there's a boondoggle-unfriendly wind blowing through the FTA. On Jan. 15, the agency wrote to BART and Metropolitan Transportation Commission brass, suggesting they might be better off scrapping plans for the Oakland Airport link, or the feds might withhold $70 million in stimulus funds. BART indeed shelved the link.

A week earlier, Rogers warned Ford that before receiving a penny of federal funds, San Francisco transit bureaucrats must analyze the city's entire transit system with the goal of proving that the Central Subway won't financially drain it into disrepair. "The plan should use realistic assumptions on growth in revenues and costs that are in line with historical experience," he wrote.

That directive suggests the federal agency won't tolerate accounting flimflam such as that highlighted in a 2006 report by engineering consultant Tom Matoff that concluded the Central Subway project was wasteful, and that its rationale was based on bogus financing and ridership numbers.

Investment in a transportation system "should represent either an opportunity to reduce operating expenses, or represent the most efficient way of bringing better service to additional markets," wrote Matoff, who had been tapped to examine the cost-effectiveness of the project. "As proposed, this project does not appear to do that — it promises to combine high capital costs with high operating costs."

San Francisco presumably took care of that detail by getting Pelosi to secure exemptions in "cost-effectiveness" requirements for federally funded transit projects, thus winning tentative funding. Soon after the report appeared, William Lieberman, the city's transportation planning director who commissioned Matoff's study, was quietly dismissed.

To Schonbrunn, the FTA's halting of the BART-airport link and its call for strong proof that the Central Subway project won't wreck Muni is a watershed moment.

"They've done something that's actually a miracle," he said. "When have I ever seen a bureaucrat put the brakes on a highly juiced project? The BART–Oakland Airport link, and the Central Subway, and BART to San Jose — these are juiced projects. They're all about politics. They have nothing to do with transportation."

So what was that big ground-breaking celebration all about if federal funding is still a long way down the track? It turns out the feds approved city plans to move public utility conduits and other infrastructure in preparation for the possibility of the project.

A call to Rogers was referred to an FTA spokesman in Washington, who hadn't responded to our spoken and written queries by press time.

About The Author

Matt Smith


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment


  • Nevada City and the South Yuba River: A gold country getaway

    Nestled in the green pine-covered hills of the Northern Sierra Nevada is the Gold Rush town of Nevada City. Beautiful Victorian houses line the streets, keeping the old-time charm alive, and a vibrant downtown is home to world-class art, theater and music. The nearby South Yuba River State Park is known for its emerald swimming holes during the summer and radiant leaf colors during autumn. These days the gold panning is more for tourists than prospectors, but the gold miner spirit is still in the air.

    South Yuba River State Park and Swimming Holes:
    The park runs along and below 20 miles of the South Yuba River, offering hiking, mountain biking, gold panning and swimming. The Highway 49 bridge swimming hole is seven-miles northwest of Nevada City where Highway 49 crosses the South Yuba River. Parking is readily available and it is a short, steep hike to a stunning swimming hole beneath a footbridge. For the more intrepid, trails extend along the river with access to secluded swim spots. The Bridgeport swimming hole has calm waters and a sandy beach -- good for families and cookouts -- and is located 14 miles northwest of Nevada City. Be sure to write down directions before heading out, GPS may not be available. Most swimming holes on the South Yuba River are best from July to September, while winter and spring can bring dangerous rapids. Always know the current before jumping in!

    Downtown Nevada City
    The welcoming, walkable downtown of Nevada City is laid back, yet full of life. Start your day at the cozy South Pine Cafe (110 S Pine St.) with a lobster benedict or a spicy Jamaican tofu scramble. Then stroll the streets and stop into the shop Kitkitdizzi (423 Broad St.) for handcrafted goods unique to the region, vintage wears and local art “all with California gold rush swagger,” as stated by owners Carrie Hawthorne and Kira Westly. Surrounded by Gold Rush history, modern gold jewelry is made from locally found nuggets and is found at Utopian Stone Custom Jewelers (301 Broad St.). For a coffee shop with Victorian charm try The Curly Wolf (217 Broad St.), an espresso house and music venue with German pastries and light fare. A perfect way to cool down during the hot summer months can be found at Treats (110 York St.) , an artisan ice cream shop with flavors like pear ginger sorbet or vegan chai coconut. Nightlife is aplenty with music halls, alehouses or dive bars like the Mine Shaft Saloon (222 Broad St.).

    The Willo Steakhouse (16898 State Hwy 49, Nevada City)
    Along Highway 49, just west of Nevada City, is The Willo, a classic roadhouse and bar where you’re welcomed by the smell of steak and a dining room full of locals. In 1947 a Quonset hut (a semi-cylindrical building) was purchased from the US Army and transported to its current location, and opened as a bar, which became popular with lumberjacks and miners. The bar was passed down through the decades and a covered structure was added to enlarge the bar and create a dining area. The original Quonset beams are still visible in the bar and current owners Mike Byrne and Nancy Wilson keep the roadhouse tradition going with carefully aged New York steaks and house made ingredients. Pair your steak or fish with a local wine, such as the Rough and Ready Red, or bring your own for a small corkage fee. Check the website for specials, such as rib-eye on Fridays.

    Outside Inn (575 E Broad St.)
    A 16-room motel a short walk from downtown, each room features a unique décor, such as the Paddlers’ Suite or the Wildflower Room. A friendly staff and an office full of information about local trails, swimming and biking gets you started on your outdoor exploration. Amenities include an outdoor shower, a summer swimming pool and picnic tables and barbeques. Don’t miss the free vegetable cart just outside the motel in the mornings.

    Written and photographed by Beth LaBerge for the SF Weekly.

  • Arcade Fire at Shoreline
    Arcade Fire opened their US tour at Shoreline Amphitheater to a full house who was there in support of their album "Reflector," which was released last fall. Dan Deacon opened the show to a happily surprised early audience and got the crowd actively dancing and warmed up. DEVO was originally on the bill to support Arcade Fire but a kayak accident last week had sidelined lead singer Mark Mothersbaugh and the duration of the west coast leg of the tour. Win Butler did a homage to DEVO by performing Uncontrollable Urge.

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed