The Men Least Likely: A Brief Survey of S.F.'s Worst Mayors

Ever since Ed Lee referred to PG&E as "a great company that gets it" during a press-friendly event featuring kiddies, baseball, and the company that blew up an adjacent town, it's been clear our mayor is not exactly a modern-day Cicero.

And yet it was difficult to ignore the odd manner in which Lee thanked Lt. Gov. Gavin Newsom — remember him? — after the latter threw in for Lee's mayoral campaign. The endorsement means an awful lot, Lee noted, as Newsom is "one of our City's most successful former mayors."

Other than removing himself from the city with haste befitting a man fleeing a nuclear test site, it's difficult to quantify just what Newsom accomplished that warrants elevation to Lee's pantheon. Sure, he's lieutenant governor, but three former city mayors have gone on to be governors, two have been senators, and one managed to land his own Chronicle column.

Still, if there's a listing of our most successful former mayors, it stands to follow we can rate our least successful ones as well. Sadly, it's not that exclusive a club:

Stephen Webb followed his tenure as mayor of San Francisco in 1855 by serving as mayor of Salem, Mass. Leading our city didn't seem to do much for Webb's upward mobility, as he was also mayor of Salem before heading west.

•If ever there was an anti-Newsom, it was George J. Whelan, the only mayor of San Francisco of whom no surviving portrait or photo exists. We know he served for six months in 1856, but no one knows when he was born or when he died. A ship named the George J. Whelan, however, sank in Lake Erie in 1930, killing 15 men. You can find photos of the boat.

•Speaking of ships, former mayor Andrew Jackson Bryant died in 1888 after allegedly throwing himself from a bay ferry in an apparent suicide.

James Phelan (mayor from 1897 to 1902) went on to high honors — he served in the U.S. Senate and has a street named after him. Retrospectively, however, his "success" is more than a bit embarrassing. One of Phelan's key campaign issues for his senate seat was a drive to "Keep California White."

George Boxton lasted only a week as mayor in 1907. Appointed after his predecessor, Eugene Schmitz, was convicted of corruption, it was quickly revealed that Boxton, too, was on the take. He lived out his days pursuing his chosen profession, dentistry, and apparently did not deign to give subsequent political endorsements.

My Voice Nation Help

I just love the way the media works.San Francisco's former mayor James D. Phelan the ex mayor that went on to become a California Senator.He's the Senator who's campaign promise to "Keep California White" was a Democrat. No where in this article was that brought out,and all the stories with links to the above were "Sanitized" as well. I had to Google his name and read the entire Wikipedia to find out for sure.It was obvious he was a Democrat in just the headline.If he had been a republican the words "Republican" and "Racist" would have been in large font in both the headline and scattered all through the article. Great fair and balance we have got going here in the media.Let us see if this passes the moderator.


@More.....Тhis is сrаzу...Мy friеnd`s sistеr mакеs 78/hr оn thе intеrnеt. Shе hаs bееn unеmрlоуеd fоr 11 mоnths but lаst mоnth hеr incоmе wаs 7985$ јust wоrкing оn thе РС fоr а fеw hоurs. Gо tо this wеb sitе .......

©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.