The Holy Land Foundation was once the largest Islamic charity in America — until it was caught violating U.S. law by funneling $12 million to Hamas. Five members of the foundation were handed life sentences in 2009 for the crime.

As part of that investigation, the feds found a memo at Holy Land's suburban Dallas headquarters. It was written in 1991 by a Muslim Brotherhood and Hamas member named Mohamed Akram. The text lays out a comical plot to institute religious Sharia law across America by using "our organizations and the organizations of our friends," MSAs included.

Never mind that in a largely Christian nation, there's zero chance that Sharia law will ever come to rule the land. Horowitz nonetheless insists that Muslim Student Associations take their marching orders from the memo.

David Horowitz at the 2011 Conservative Political Action Conference.
Gage Skidmore
David Horowitz at the 2011 Conservative Political Action Conference.
The Horowitz Freedom Center “Where Are They Now?” ad that ran in campus news papers including the Jan. 23, 2012, edition of The Lantern at Ohio State University.
The Horowitz Freedom Center “Where Are They Now?” ad that ran in campus news papers including the Jan. 23, 2012, edition of The Lantern at Ohio State University.

"I see it as a recruitment organization," he says. "Its purpose is first to isolate the Muslim students, to create a Muslim center so they're not going to assimilate into Western values. I know this from my youth in Communist front associations. The idea is you create a group that gathers all the Muslim kids, and then you identify the ones who become leaders. Those are the ones who get positions of power in the organization, and those are the ones who go on to do other Muslim Brotherhood tasks."

Yet there's little evidence that the memo was ever put into play outside of the overactive imagination of its author.

"It's one memo that they found that some crazy guy had written that was never in any way accepted by anyone or implemented anywhere, even by the Muslim Brotherhood," says Haris Tarin, director of the Washington, D.C., office of the Muslim Public Affairs Council. "The idea of American Muslims on college campuses who've never been to places like Egypt having some affinity to the Muslim Brotherhood is absurd."

Still, Sharia law has become a bogeyman for even seemingly sensible conservatives. Two years ago, Oklahoma passed a constitutional amendment — with 70 percent of the vote — banning its use in state courts. For Horowitz, it's a topic that reliably kicks up dust at colleges.

Last January, the Ohio State University student paper ran the same "Where Are They Now?" ad that appeared at Florida State. The Lantern's staff was pummeled with e-mails and calls from students. Horowitz chimed in from the sidelines, clearly enjoying the furor.

Freedom Center ads are almost a yearly rite at UCLA, where the Daily Bruin regularly receives alternating waves of attacks and counterattacks. One side clamors for a muzzle, the other wants Horowitz to have his say.

"At MSA, we've met with the communications department and made it clear we don't want David Horowitz's ad published," says Haidar Anwar, a UCLA student who serves as president of MSA West, an umbrella group. "We've brought it up to the dean of students as well. But after we met with them, David Horowitz published another ad."

If your business involves pissing people off, it's important to have steady reports of success from the front lines. Each new episode of tumult adds a fresh coat of paint to your image as an effective instigator. That's what funders want to see.

From 2001 to 2009, groups like Horowitz's received $42 million in donations — mostly from large conservative charities, according to the Center for American Progress. All that money provides incentive to sharpen one's attacks.

"These people are very deliberate in how they do things," says Tarin. "Some of them focus on college campuses. Some of them focus on law enforcement. Some of them focus on churches and Rotary clubs and senior-citizen homes. It's an industry."

Horowitz swats down any talk about his role in spreading Islamophobia. Because his work is mainly focused on campuses, he can wrap himself snugly in the First Amendment and claim he's just offering up another academic perspective. "If you use the words 'Muslim' and 'terrorist' in a sentence or a paragraph, you're an Islamophobe," he says. "That's just an attempt to silence critics, which is what I am. I am not a person who is hostile to Muslims."

But when you start peddling these ideas outside that campus bubble, the chances increase that you'll not only reach a touchy college liberal, but also the mosque-burner at Florida State. And Horowitz still has an active hand in such wider messaging. Two high-profile names sharing his brainwaves and support are Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller.

As the man behind Jihad Watch, Spencer is on the Freedom Center payroll. Geller runs a blog called Atlas Shrugs and was a recipient of a Freedom Center award for courage. Together they founded Stop the Islamization of America (SIOA). Both are full-throttled in their excoriation of all things Muslim — so much so that the SIOA has landed on the Southern Poverty Law Center's list of hate groups, along with the Ku Klux Klan and the Aryan Brotherhood.

"I think Horowitz is just coming up to the line of Islamophobia and not stepping over it," says Heidi Beirich, director of the Southern Poverty Law Center's Intelligence Project. "But he's perfectly happy to fund it."

« Previous Page
Next Page »
My Voice Nation Help

It's so important to write about prejudice, to offer alternative view-points and to dissect the simplicity and disrespect of those that blatantly nurture and perpetrate intolerance. 

But to do so with the same simplistic, blatant means? Reading this article left me with a really bad taste - Kyle Swenson uses the same lame tactics he denounces and thus greatly cheapens his effort. A few examples: "Muslim Hunting" - the title. I doubt Kyle Swenson has ever been hunting or else he wouldn't have used such lurid comparison. "A white-meat gathering"?? Why should this kind of disrespect towards one race be ok but not towards others? There is no room for ambivalence in our efforts for mutual respect (perhaps Kyle Swenson suffers from a case of self-hatred? I assume he is Caucasian). And also his mentioning of funding is completely one-sided and doesn't allow the reader to get a comprehensive picture.

red.marcy.rand topcommenter

Horowitz is the Ashkenazi male version of a Yenta. He's a perpetual crank in league with Jihadists of the Right like the Ayn Rand Institute and its crazed founder Leonard Peikoff, Pam Geller, Robert Spencer and other such Israel First warmongering trash. Occasionally he's right on the reparations for blacks issue and a few others but mostly he's a windbag in it for the big bucks. Being a left radical in Berkeley never paid off like this but being a right radical gets you a Bel Air mansion. Friedfish, thanks for your cogent comments on Obama's statist fascism. However thank Allah Romney-Ryan lost. We had this Zionist nut Lee Rodgers spreading anti-Arab racism for years at KGO and then KSFO. Is that latter station even still around ?


My goodness! The Left admits that David Horowitz - a Conservative - can be correct at times? The staff of SF Weekly will have to sent to re-education camp!

The main disgrace that the Left sweeps under the rug (Islamic prayer rug?) is that Obama has intensified the Bush-originated SWAT tactics against the Muslim residents and Muslim citizens in the US. I, a conservative Independent, had always objected to Bush-built Homeland Security network. An yet, Obama gave more powers to Homeland Security. Obama is making the USA more militarized and making the US and the US government becoming more and more fascist (government control - not necessarily ownership - of all means of production). This is the disgrace that the Left hides from the public.

©2014 SF Weekly, LP, All rights reserved.