Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Friday, September 24, 2010

San Francisco's Best Chocolate Chip Cookies

Posted By on Fri, Sep 24, 2010 at 2:03 PM

click to enlarge The Goody Goodie (and cookie cognates) from Goody Goodie Cream and Sugar. - JOHN BIRDSALL
  • John Birdsall
  • The Goody Goodie (and cookie cognates) from Goody Goodie Cream and Sugar.
Not cool enough to be retro, not colorful enough to be campy, the chocolate chip cookie inhabits that limbo of foods we take for granted yet can't quite do without. It seems to hang in stasis, seemingly unchanged from the ones we loved as kids. And yet, after the extravagance of pastry chefs' chocolate chip cookies in the '80s and early '90s ― all opulent hunks of hand-hewn bittersweet and outré nuts like pistachios and macadamias ― San Francisco's bakers have settled into a quieter cookie, one that minds its ingredients but doesn't stray far from Ruth Wakefield's Toll House recipe of the 1930s. Here are six local versions we like a lot.

1. Goody Goodie Cream and Sugar: 1246 Folsom (at Eighth St.).

Pastry chef/owner Remi Hayashi boasts that her walk-up dessert salon's eponymous cookie has a chocolate-to-dough ratio of four-to-one. Oh, and that chocolate? High-class E. Guittard, in a range of cacao percentages ranging from milk to 72 percent ― all in the same cookie. $2.75

Grade: A

click to enlarge Designed to spread: Mr. and Mrs. Miscellaneous chocolate chip cookies. - JOHN BIRDSALL
  • John Birdsall
  • Designed to spread: Mr. and Mrs. Miscellaneous chocolate chip cookies.
2. Mr. and Mrs. Miscellaneous: 699 22nd St. (at Third St.).

Ian Flores developed his high-fat, high-sugar cookie off and on over three years. He likes the way it spreads and caramelizes in the oven; we like the way it stays chewy. Chocolate in the classic cookie is Cacao Barry; in Flores' chocolate-dried cherry spinoff, it's 70 percent Valrhona Guanaja. Both cookies cost $2 each.

Grade: A-

  • Pin It

Tags: , , , , , ,

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook

Slideshows

  • Trixxie Carr Presents: Maneater at Oasis
    January 14, 2015 was the first night of Trixxie Carr Presents: Maneater at Oasis in San Francisco. Photos by Calibree Photography.
  • No Pants BART Ride 2015 - NSFW
    The No Pants BART Ride commenced on Sunday, Jan. 11, 2015. Participants rode without pants, and at the end of the ride they disembarked at The Mission to bar hop, eat burritos and take selfies. Photos by Richard Haick.