Collecting records is more than a simple hobby. The Internet has changed the game dramatically: While it's much easier to find that once-elusive LP, you now have more cut-throat competition between buyers, driving up prices on rare finds. Every genre has its crown jewels, but one of the most sought-after and expensive LPs of the acid-rock world is the 1968 self-titled debut from the New Tweedy Bros!, a band with roots in the late-'60s San Francisco music scene. Dog-eared copies of the original album will set you back about $750. If you want a sealed copy, call your bank, as those were going for as high as $4,000 a pop on eBay as recently as last week.
The New Tweedy Bros! contains jug band stompers, creepy dirges, and hazy pop songs, all dusted with the finest LSD the era could offer. The opening seconds of the first song, “Somebody's Peepin,” for example, immediately set the uneasy mood. The track has that slight whiff of danger all good acid rock contains, reflected in the lyrics (sung in spooky a cappella and double-tracked with an overlapping effect): “Somebody's peepin' into my room/Could it be someone who knows my name?/Somebody's trying to break down my door/I guess I'd probably do the same.” The New Tweedy Bros! offers ten remarkable tracks with a multitude of instruments, including autoharp, washboard, cans, fiddle, and kazoo. But it's the LP's cover that gets the band the most attention. Frontman Fred Lackaff designed the die-cut, triple-gatefold, foil-finished hexagon-shaped packaging. It was a straight-up masterpiece: a great record with an amazingly over-the-top jacket from a group whose life span was a quick two years and whose mysterious history only adds to its legacy.
The New Tweedy Bros! formed in Portland, Oregon, in early 1966. Lackaff sang and played guitar, his brother Danny was the drummer, Dennis Fagaly was the bassist, and Steve Ekman was lead guitarist. The Northwest sound at that time was mostly known for frenetic R&B bands like the Sonics and the Wailers. The Tweedy Bros! were far removed from that world, incorporating elements from jug bands and folk acts as well as jangly guitars, fuzzy basslines, and distinctive vocal harmonies. They wasted no time finding more fertile creative soil and ended up in San Francisco later that spring, right when the city's acid-rock scene was reaching its creative zenith. One of the Tweedy Bros' first shows was opening for the Grateful Dead at the Avalon, where they later shared the stage with Big Brother, who were debuting a new singer named Janis Joplin.
Take a listen to the Tweedy Bros' ultra-rare 1966 single (“Good Time Car” b/w “Terms Of”), recorded for the DOT label. You can hear a kinship with the great early San Francisco psych-rock groups: the Charlatans, the Mystery Trend, the Great Society, Sopwith Camel. They share a sound devoid of pretension, but there's a cutting-edge wink in the music hinting that the band is in on something bigger.
The New Tweedy Bros! had a busy six-month run before returning to Portland for the holidays in 1967. But times weren't easy: Authorities in both cities were growing suspicious of late-night dances with rock music. Soon promoters were having trouble getting the required licenses to hold such events. For a band like the Tweedy Bros., who didn't want to play bars, jobs dried up. Fagaly was first to leave and start a family. “None of us had any day jobs for the two years I was in the band,” says Fagaly, who currently lives in the Bay Area. “We made our living out of this.”
By the end of 1968, The New Tweedy Bros! had called it quits. Yet before they faded into history, they recorded for Portland's tiny Ridon label their self-titled debut, which would keep their name around much longer than anyone expected.
Once The New Tweedy Bros! was completed (the covers were hand-assembled by the band members), the albums were sold at shows and distributed to local stores. But here's the rub: When record clerks took this masterpiece out of the box, they realized it wouldn't fit on the shelves. Those six corners were in the way, and ended up getting bent. The album was almost impossible to store, so it was kept behind the counter, out of eyesight from curious buyers. With no major label to promote it, sales were low. Tragically, when the band ordered another run of the album art later in 1968, the pressing plant had a fire, and all future covers were lost. (That fact alone heightens the record's collectability.)
Psych-rock advocates have been seeking out The New Tweedy Bros! throughout the years. It's been bootlegged a number of times, and alternate covers have been used to package the music, but no one has gone to the lengths of Shadoks, the German reissue imprint. In the late '90s, Shadoks owner Thomas Hartlage decided he wanted to create the preeminent reissue of the album. He discovered the band members owned a stack of unplayed vinyl copies as well as the master plates for the cover, a coup in the reissue world. Around the same time, the band finally came into possession of a digital copy of its master tapes. Yet Hartlage was impatient: One insider tells me the label owner pressed his vinyl reissue using a mint-condition copy of the record — what collectors call a “needle drop.”
On the upside, Shadoks' CD version of The New Tweedy Bros!, released in 2001, is almost as good as the original because Hartlage held out for the authentic source material. The label also created an exact miniature replica of the original cover, right down to the printing on the spine … and it doesn't fit into the shelves, either. Showing the true absurdity of the reissue world, though, the Shadoks vinyl version is now also out of print.
So, collectors, which version of The New Tweedy Bros! do you want: the real deal or an almost exact copy? Your decision will depend on how much you want to shell out. Shadoks' releases, containing honest-to-God vinyl from 1968, are priced anywhere from $100 to $175, when they become available. To own the 40-year-old original LP with a hand-assembled cover, however, is a Holy Grail in music collecting: A copy will set you back anywhere from $300 to $4,000 (depending on condition, of course). The New Tweedy Bros! is a piece of San Francisco history as well as a piece of art. Best of all, you can still dance to it.