Looking ahead to 2017, SF Weekly explored several topics about trends we (might) expect in the year to come. Read the other stories, about the resurgence of protest songs, the future of fast-casual restaurants in S.F., and the feasibility of time travel.
If you’ve been to a concert in the last few years, surely you’ve seen them: dozens upon dozens of cellphones hovering above the audience — and, most likely, blocking your view. But it’s not just the view-blocking that is annoying about cellphone use at shows, nor is it only audience members who have beef with their rampant use. More and more artists and bands are fed up with cellphones at shows, and are arguing they not only distract the crowd and ruin the overall vibe, but lead to piracy and leaks, especially if they choose to unveil new material.
“[Without phones], there exists a somewhat mythical rave ideal, a crowd singularly in tune with the music,” says San Francisco producer and DJ Lane 8, who, along with musicians like Alicia Keys and the Lumineers, has started banning phones. “If half of the crowd is on their phones at a show, it is literally impossible to create that atmosphere.”
Lane 8’s means of nixing the devices includes putting tape over the camera lens and enlisting extra security to make sure no one peels it off. Others, like Prince and the bands She & Him, the Yeah Yeahs Yeahs, and the Savages, have opted for more passive solutions, such as posting signs outside the venue or relying on security to do the heavy lifting by shining lights in phone users’ faces or removing people from the venue.
And then there’s Yondr, a startup that makes self-locking pouches that can’t be opened unless they’re demagnetized. The beauty behind this invention — which has been used by everyone from Keys to Dave Chappelle — is that it allows concertgoers to hold their phones, without opting for more drastic measures like locking them up.
But even this contrivance has its cons.
A fan who attended Childish Gambino’s September shows in Joshua Tree, where concertgoers were body-searched and made to use Yondr’s pouches, said that the ordeal was a nuisance, requiring fans to wait in long lines before and after the show to lock and unlock their phones.
And even then, the self-locking pouches didn’t always work.
“It was really easy to pop open with a finger,” she says. “Security saw one dude who got his phone out and they made him delete his photos. But there are videos and photos of his show out there, so obviously it didn’t work.”
Foolproof these solutions are not, but it’s likely the cellphone crackdown will get more stringent in the next few months, so be forewarned.
Jessie Schiewe is the music editor of SF Weekly.