Get SF Weekly Newsletters
Pin It

Doctor Everybody: A Local Startup Relies on "Crowd Wisdom" for Medical Advice 

Tuesday, Aug 19 2014
Comments (1)

As any voracious Googler can attest, relying on the wisdom of crowds is a dicey practice, particularly when it comes to medical diagnosis. No matter how strange the query (Will the microwave fry my ovaries? Does this headache signify a brain aneurysm?) there's always a pool of babbling internet trolls dispensing unhelpful advice.

All the same, internet-driven diagnostics have earned newfound cachet in recent years, owing to a few high-profile cases and a broader movement to bring Big Data into medicine. Last year, IBM announced that its supercomputer, Watson, is better at diagnosing cancer than any human doctor. In March, 20,000 social media users petitioned a biotech company to use experimental medication on a dying 7-year-old. Then in July, The New Yorker profiled a young boy with a disease that's new to science; his father sought treatment in the blogosphere.

Meanwhile, a San Francisco startup called CrowdMed is presenting its own alternative system, inviting users to submit queries to an online community of "medical detectives." The detectives — a mix of doctors, nurses, researchers, med students, and laymen — offer recommendations which in turn get vetted and ranked by their peers. It's not a bona fide treatment plan, CrowdMed founder Jared Heyman cautions. But it saves the patient from visiting scores of experts before returning to her doctor.

Heyman speaks from firsthand experience: His sister spent three years with a medical condition that took dozens of doctors and six-figure medical bills to solve. CrowdMed cracked her case in a few weeks, he says.

Yet some medical ethicists, among them University of Southern California law professor Michael Shapiro, aren't entirely persuaded by the company's marketing pitch.

"It's hard to see crowdsourcing as such as the practice of medicine," Shapiro writes via email, with the caveat that people are certainly free to do research, and crowds are free to opine, so long as they don't hold themselves out as licensed professionals. (Most of the site's medical detectives remain anonymous.)

However, he says, if these detectives are indeed presenting themselves as groups of physicians, then they may be opening the door for lawsuits or regulatory snarls. Liability is a sticky thing, and it depends largely on whether the detectives' "solutions" are interpreted as mere hypotheses or actual diagnoses. The latter carries a lot more risk than the former.

Then again, not seeking information is risky, too. And, Shapiro notes, anyone who tries to sue CrowdMed might run into both the First and 14th Amendments, which protect individual liberty and personal security (i.e., the right to protect oneself medically by seeking information). "Free speech poses risks," Shapiro writes, "but squishing it is way worse." Thus, "crowd wisdom" might be better than no wisdom at all.

About The Author

Rachel Swan

Rachel Swan

Rachel Swan has been a staff writer at SF Weekly since 2013. In previous lives she was a music editor, IP hack, and tutor of Cal athletes.


Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment


  • 24th Annual Autumn Moon Festival
    Crowds gathered September 6-7 for the 24th Annual Autumn Moon Festival in Chinatown. Visitors enjoyed arts, crafts, cultural exhibits, food and a dog fashion show. Photographs by Dhoryan Rizo.
  • Felton: Touring the Redwoods
    Blue skies meet redwood canopies in the mountain town of Felton, located just north of Santa Cruz on Highway 9. Once a bustling logging community, the town is now a mix of mellow locals and serene wilderness. Visitors can enjoy the redwoods in nearby Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park and splash in swimming holes in the San Lorenzo River. For a bite to eat stop by Rocky’s Cafe for fruit-laden pancakes, barbeque at the Cowboy Bar & Grill and poolside burgers at the Trout Farm Inn. Other stops worth checking out include Roaring Camp Railroads, the Mount Hermon zip line tour, and the educational Bigfoot Discovery Museum. For beer or cocktails a log cabin bar has you covered.

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed