Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Friday, October 21, 2011

Britney and Rihanna Debut New Videos -- and Anti-English Sentiments

Posted By on Fri, Oct 21, 2011 at 8:38 AM

click to enlarge Rihanna_608x340.jpg

This week, both Rihanna and Britney Spears debuted gritty videos for their latest singles. In Rihanna's "We Found Love", we see the singer exploring sex, drugs, and horrible apartments. In Britney's "Criminal," we see her slapped in the face by a dude, shot at by cops, and naked in a shower with her boyfriend. These girls are going out of their way to prove they're not bubblegum pop stars. But interestingly, both chose a British setting to demonstrate their grit.


Britney's gun-toting video caused such an uproar in the U.K. that London's Houses of Parliament -- Britain's center of government -- felt the need to have a discussion about it before the video had even debuted. The U.K. is not a place that readily embraces guns. Rather, it's a place where guns are rare, gun licensing is tightly controlled, and the entire establishment has been in a panic about gun use on its streets for the last three years. (That's due to increased gun crime in the country -- something that has traditionally been attributable only to the mob and organized crime.) So it's interesting to see that, when going for the most low-down, dirty environments they could think of, both vocalists chose to film in the U.K. -- a place where you're far less likely to find shooting victims than America.


Rihanna's video embraces Trainspotting-esque visuals -- she's seen repeatedly in front of a backdrop of council estates (the British version of the projects); she's seen at a pseudo-rave in a field -- something that the British invented; and she has Calvin Harris, one of Britain's biggest DJs, there to legitimize it all. The voiceover at the beginning of the video is inexplicably done by someone from the north of England. Rihanna wears skinhead garb -- the Doc Martens boots, the cropped green jacket. She's seen in front of that most British of institutions -- the fish 'n' chip shop -- while constantly telling us what a "hopeless place" this is.

But she's also depicted repeatedly in front of -- or wearing -- American flags, as if to repeatedly emphasize her otherness to this horrible environment. Like she doesn't really belong there because she's American, and therefore, somehow, better. The video ends with her abandoning all the hedonism and self-destruction that England, and her English boyfriend, has inspired in her, and abandoning it for something we assume must be more positive. It begs the question: is she trying to tell us that she's better than this environment? Is she above being in this very, very British shithole -- the same place that makes Britney turn bad?

click to enlarge criminal.jpg

That anti-British sentiment continues in Britney's "Criminal." The start of the video features her being verbally and physically abused by the most English man on earth. It is, of course, an American that rescues her. An American criminal -- but in this context, even an American criminal is better than an upper-class Englishman. What's more, she later gets shot at by a whole army of British policemen -- even though only a small portion of the U.K. police force are even permitted to carry guns, and when they do so, they are incredibly cautious about it.

So what does this all mean? Well, it's mostly incredibly ironic. Both Britney and Rihanna have chosen to film their grittiest videos in a country with a lower crime rate than the U.S. -- one that is so aghast at gun use that its politicians feel the need to talk about the exploits of a pop star, in the context of a music video, in the highest echelons of their government. Is this racism of sorts? Or at least xenophobia? Well, pretty much, yes.

America has a tradition of portraying British people as villains, mostly in its movies, and these videos only serve to reproduce a stereotype that Britain is bad -- that it inspires the worst in everyone; that the police are gun-happy; and the people are drug-addicted arse-holes. From Star Wars, through Constantine, to the Silence Of The Lambs and beyond, the English are among the most evil motherfuckers on earth, according to American pop culture. Doesn't this seem strange, what with them being our allies and everything? As stupidly offensive as Dick Van Dyke's cock-er-ney geezer was in Mary Poppins, it was still better than the widespread idea that British people live in the most dangerous place on earth and wish to bring us all down to their level with their pernicious ways. 

Both Britney's and Rihanna's videos are accomplished visually, and as mini-movies. But in the future, artists and directors should stop hating on the British so much.

----
Follow us on Twitter @SFAllShookDown, follow Rae Alexandra @Raemondjjjj, and like us at Facebook.com/SFAllShookDown.

  • Pin It

Tags: , , , , , , ,

About The Author

Rae Alexandra

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook

Slideshows

  • Cirque du Soleil Returns to San Francisco
    Cirque du Soleil returns to AT&T park with their current production Kurious: Cabinet of Curiosities. Photographs by Richard Haick.
  • Slayer @ Fox Theater
    Slayer, Exodus and Suicidal Tendencies performed at the Fox Theater in Oakland on November 12, 2014. Photographs by Richard Haick.