Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Wednesday, July 8, 2009

Fish Story: Sierra Club Lawsuit Claims Unlawful Water Diversion Terminating Trout

Posted By on Wed, Jul 8, 2009 at 6:30 AM

click to enlarge Mr. Trout, siding with the plaintiffs... - ROD SUTTERBY
  • Rod Sutterby
  • Mr. Trout, siding with the plaintiffs...
Anyone who's ever seen Show Boat knows that "Fish gotta swim." Also, "Birds gotta fly" and "I gotta love one man 'til I die." The first of these needs was addressed in a recent federal lawsuit filed in San Francisco by The Sierra Club and the Carmel River Steelhead Association against the government and the California American Water Company alleging the latter's unlawful water diversions in the Carmel River have left the state's steelhead trout out to dry -- literally.

The suit claims that California American has been diverting nearly four times the amount of water it is legally allowed from the river for agricultural irrigation (up to 11,285 acre-feet when 3,376 acre-feet is the annual limit. Incidentally, an "acre-foot" is the amount of water -- or pudding, or whatever -- required to flood one acre of land one foot deep. That's about 325,851 gallons. That's not nothing).

The environmentalists claim that this year only 95 steelheads were counted beneath San Clemente Dam -- a 17-year low. While the defendants think it's ridiculous to blame this on the river being pumped dry -- well, the Sierra Club et al. see things differently.

The plaintiffs demand an immediate 35 percent reduction in water diversions -- and that's just for starters -- with the eventual goal being that the endangered fish can reach and surmount the San Clemente Dam. Or, as they put it in legalese :

California American has not obtained an incidental take permit under Section 10 of the ESA, nor has it sought approval by NMFS of a Section 10 habitat conservation plan, regarding the effects of the operation of its diversions on steelhead. In consequence, Cal-Am does not have an incidental take permit for its operation of the Project and is strictly liable under Section 9 and the regulations promulgated udner ESA for any taking of threatened steelhead in the SCCC DPS that results in harm to steelhad from such operation.
Not as pleasing to the ear as "Fish gotta swim, birds gotta fly," no. Then again, Rodgers and Hammerstein never went to law school.

Note: Despite earlier reports in this article and elsewhere, the water diverted by California Water is not being used for agricultural purposes. Plaintiffs attorney Laurens Silver affirms that "95 percent" of the water in question is being used for "urban purposes" in cities like Monterey and Seaside. 

H/T   |   Courthouse News

  • Pin It

Tags: , , ,

About The Author

Joe Eskenazi

Joe Eskenazi

Bio:
Joe Eskenazi was born in San Francisco, raised in the Bay Area, and attended U.C. Berkeley. He never left. "Your humble narrator" was a staff writer and columnist for SF Weekly from 2007 to 2015. He resides in the Excelsior with his wife, 4.3 miles from his birthplace and 5,474 from hers.

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook

Slideshows

  • Permanent Residents

    San Francisco is not just skin deep to these folks — it's a permanent resident of their bodies and souls. They may be scattered far and wide — everywhere from Bernal Heights to Brooklyn, El Paso, Tokyo, and beyond — but the one thing these self-defined San Franciscans all share is a deep commitment to the city by the Bay.

    Interviewers: Matt Saincome, Julia Carrie Wong, and Peter Lawrence Kane

  • SF Pride Parade 2015
    A sea of spectators gathered along Market Street on Sunday, June 28 for the SF Pride Parade. Photographs by Calibree Photography.