Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Thursday, June 3, 2010

Michela Alioto-Pier Files to Run for Supe Again. Will Suit Against City Be Next?

Posted By on Thu, Jun 3, 2010 at 12:15 PM

click to enlarge Are Michela Alioto-Pier and the city on a collision course?
  • Are Michela Alioto-Pier and the city on a collision course?
City's Department of Elections does not consider District 2 Supervisor Michela Alioto-Pier eligible to defend her seat

Two years after City Attorney Dennis Herrera filed an opinion stating Michela Alioto-Pier was ineligible to run for re-election, the District 2 supe took out papers this morning to do just that. There's a simple difference of opinion here: Herrera thinks Alioto-Pier is termed out and she thinks she isn't. A judge may have to decide the matter. "I am not ruling out a lawsuit -- absolutely not," she told SF Weekly last year.

While Alioto-Pier would probably much rather concentrate on fund-raising and politicking in what figures to be a contested race against Janet Reilly, a lawsuit became a much more realistic possibility just moments ago. John Arntz, the head of the city's Department of Elections, told SF Weekly he will follow Herrera's opinion and block Alioto-Pier from appearing on the ballot.

"At this point, she is not considered eligible for ballot in November," he said.

You can read Arntz' terse letter to Alioto-Pier here: SupAlioto-PierLtr.pdf

Alioto-Pier is legally represented by the influential political svengali Jim Sutton -- and in parsing Herrera's ruling he may have some great material to work with.

The crux of Herrera's opinion is that, per the city charter, public

servants "appointed ... to complete in excess of two years of a

four-year term"

will be deemed to have served a full term. However, Alioto-Pier points

out that she was in 2004 appointed by Gavin Newsom to fill his vacant

seat, won a special election for a two-year term 10 months later, and

then won re-election to a four-year term in 2007. By her calculation, she's in the tail end of her first four-year term. 

What's more, following

the passage of Proposition C in 2001, it is now impossible to hold an

appointed position for "in excess of two years." City law now mandates

that appointees must run in special elections between 120 and 365 days

of their appointment -- as Alioto-Pier successfully did. 

click to enlarge Dennis Herrera's term limits opinion has been a menace for Michela Alioto-Pier - JIM HERD
  • Jim Herd
  • Dennis Herrera's term limits opinion has been a menace for Michela Alioto-Pier
It also warrants mentioning that, when it comes to determining term limits, two-year terms and four-year terms are not synonymous. The difference between the two led to a Herrera ruling that eventually allowed Tom Ammiano to serve 14 years on the Board of Supervisors

Calls to Herrera's office led to his spokesmen referring to the city attorney's rulings regarding Alioto-Pier and Ammiano's term-limit situations (just as it has every time we've queried about this). You can read both of those opinions online, here and here, respectively.

Alioto-Pier's camp has one more bullet in its bandoleer it hopes will stave off the possibility of a lawsuit. Eight months after Herrera's ruling regarding Alioto-Pier's eligibility, a 2008 charter amendment would have given voters the chance to clear up this very question.

Proposition F called for moving all odd-year elections into even years as a cost-saver. But it also would have established "limits of two successive 4-year terms for the Mayor and members of the Board of Supervisors. Any partial term of two or more years counts as a full term." That applies to elected terms, appointed terms, terms decided by pulling Excalibur out of a stone, whatever.

Prop. F lost, garnering only 45 percent of the vote.

Alioto-Pier was in rules committee today and has not yet returned SF Weekly's calls.

Follow us on Twitter at @TheSnitchSF and @SFWeekly

Photo of Dennis Herrera   |   Jim Herd

  • Pin It

Tags: , , , , , , ,

About The Author

Joe Eskenazi

Joe Eskenazi

Joe Eskenazi was born in San Francisco, raised in the Bay Area, and attended U.C. Berkeley. He never left. "Your humble narrator" is a staff writer and columnist for SF Weekly, which he has written for since 2007. He resides in the Excelsior with his wife, 4.3 miles from his birthplace and 5,474 from hers... more


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook


  • 24th Annual Autumn Moon Festival
    Crowds gathered September 6-7 for the 24th Annual Autumn Moon Festival in Chinatown. Visitors enjoyed arts, crafts, cultural exhibits, food and a dog fashion show. Photographs by Dhoryan Rizo.
  • Felton: Touring the Redwoods
    Blue skies meet redwood canopies in the mountain town of Felton, located just north of Santa Cruz on Highway 9. Once a bustling logging community, the town is now a mix of mellow locals and serene wilderness. Visitors can enjoy the redwoods in nearby Henry Cowell Redwoods State Park and splash in swimming holes in the San Lorenzo River. For a bite to eat stop by Rocky’s Cafe for fruit-laden pancakes, barbeque at the Cowboy Bar & Grill and poolside burgers at the Trout Farm Inn. Other stops worth checking out include Roaring Camp Railroads, the Mount Hermon zip line tour, and the educational Bigfoot Discovery Museum. For beer or cocktails a log cabin bar has you covered.