Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Thursday, September 15, 2011

City Attorney Says DNA Lab Memo Is Exempt from Public Records Act

Posted By on Thu, Sep 15, 2011 at 7:00 AM

click to enlarge Rockne Harmon co-authored a controversial internal memo on crime lab problems
  • Rockne Harmon co-authored a controversial internal memo on crime lab problems

We reported Tuesday that City Attorney Dennis Herrera's office, contrary to assertions made at a public debate last week by District Attorney George Gascón, had not provided an opinion as to whether a controversial internal memo on problems at the city's police DNA lab should be released to the public.

Well, in 24 hours -- or less -- a lot can change.

Herrera spokesman Jack Song said yesterday that his office requested and reviewed the memo on Tuesday, the same day our story was published. Lawyers who reviewed it are of the opinion that it would be exempt from disclosure under the California Public Records Act, he said.

"Yesterday, after your article ran, our office approached the DA's office and said, 'Let us look at the memo,'" Song told SF Weekly. "We looked at it and determined that it is part of the attorney work product [exemption]."

Under state law governing the release of public records, a "work product" exemption exists for "writing that reflects an attorney's impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal research or theories."

The opinion of the city attorney's office on the DNA lab memo applies only to public-records requests, Song noted, and not to criminal cases. In the latter, defense lawyers could still be entitled to the document as evidence in their clients' cases.

The opinion from the city attorney's office was the latest twist in the slowly unfurling saga of the memo, which was authored by renowned DNA expert and veteran prosecutor Rockne Harmon in 2010. Harmon has said he believes the document, which highlights shortcomings in the SFPD crime lab's DNA-testing procedures, is "germane to future legal issues" and should be released to defense lawyers.

However, the DA's office has gone to great lengths to keep the document hidden, going so far as to initially claim it did not exist. This assertion was made despite the fact that the memo's co-author was Braden Woods, chief of the DA's criminal division, according to Harmon.

After the memo's disclosure became an issue in the DA's race this month, Gascón publicly acknowledged the memo's existence for the first time but claimed that his office was under no obligation to release it to either criminal defendants or the public. At a large debate sponsored by the Bar Association of San Francisco last week, he said the city attorney supported this stance.

"We went one additional step, and had a discussion with the city attorney," Gascón said. "The city attorney has also reviewed this and has opined that this is work product."

On Monday, however, Song said the city attorney's office had not reviewed the memo. The document was not given to deputy city attorneys until Tuesday, almost a week after Gascón's comments, according to Song.

DA spokesperson Erica Derryck issued the following statement in response to questions about Gascón's assertions last week: "The initial determination made by the City Attorney's Office that the work

product in question is in fact privileged stands even after specific review

and is therefore is entirely consistent with the general guidance

previously sought and provided."

Follow us on Twitter at @SFWeekly and @TheSnitchSF

  • Pin It

Tags: , , , , , , , , , ,

About The Author

Peter Jamison


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook


  • Phish at the Bill Graham Auditorium
    Phish is in the midst of a block of sold out shows at the Bill Graham Civic Auditorium (October 27-29). The Monday night concert featured a rare first set opener of “Walfredo” with the band members switching instruments for the song. The evening’s highlights included John Fishman and his iconic vacuum cleaner solo and favorites such as Chalk Dust Torture, Slave to the Traffic Light, Axilla, Rift, 2001 Space Odyssey, and Maze. The show also featured Phish’s debut of a, seemingly impromptu, version of “Take Me Out to the Ballgame” to with roaring approval of the, singing along, crowd. With Game 6 being tonight, partying Phish fans will join Giants fans in Civic Center Plaza where there will be a World Series viewing party on a large screen set up by the City. Photography by Jamie Soja.
  • The 4th Annual Masquerotica 2014 - NSFW
    The theme this year was Carnaval Mystique for the 4th Annual Masquerotica at The Factory. Attendees were entertained by strip dance, trapeze, and live music. Photographs by Calibree Photography.