Get SF Weekly Newsletters

Wednesday, October 3, 2012

Nikolaus Crumbley Homicide: Jury Deadlocked on Cold Case Murder

Posted By on Wed, Oct 3, 2012 at 12:00 PM

click to enlarge Nikolaus Crumbley, victim
  • Nikolaus Crumbley, victim

A San Francisco jury deadlocked on whether a local man was responsible for strangling Nikolaus Crumbley and leaving his body at McLaren Park nearly three decades ago.

District Attorney George Gascón said that despite DNA evidence linking 48-year-old William Payne to the crime scene, the jury could not reach a unanimous verdict. 

"DNA evidence and independent corroborating testimony linked the defendant to the brutal rape and murder of Mr. Crumbley," Gascón said. "We are disappointed with the outcome and will be evaluating how to proceed with the case."

Payne, who was a teenager at the time of the incident, was arrested in January at Walden House -- a substance abuse treatment center -- on suspicion

of killing 41-year-old Crumbley, who was visiting from Texas. Police linked Payne to

DNA evidence taken from a swab of Crumbley's rectum during his autopsy.

click to enlarge William Payne
  • William Payne
Crumbley was a civilian employee with the military and was in town on business, police said. On Nov. 16, 1983, police found Crumbley strangled in McLaren Park; he had his pants and his underwear pulled down to his knees. Crumbley was last seen before his death with another man at a local hotel.

The San Francisco Medical Examiner's Office ruled the victim's death a homicide and the cause of death from ligature strangulation. The San Francisco Crime Lab was notified by the California Department of Justice that via their DNA database, a match was identified between the DNA evidence sample was taken from the victim as well as Payne.

Follow us on Twitter at @TheSnitchSF

and @SFWeekly

  • Pin It

Tags: , , ,

About The Author

Erin Sherbert

Erin Sherbert

Erin Sherbert has been Online News Editor for SF Weekly since 2010. She's a Texas native and has a closet full of cowboy boots to prove it.


Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

Popular Stories

  1. Most Popular Stories
  2. Stories You Missed

Like us on Facebook


  • Giants World Series Parade 2014
    Crowds of Giants fans braved the rainy weather on Halloween day to watch the parade for the San Francisco Giants after their third World Series win in five years. Fans climbed trees, bus stop over-hangs, newspaper stands and anything else that they could manage to balance on. Photographs by Mike Hendrickson
  • King Diamond @ The Warfield
    King Diamond with Jess and The Ancient Ones performed last night at the Warfield on Thursday, October 30th. Photographs by Richard Haick.