Categories: News

DA Declines to Retry Gun Conviction in Steinle Case


A judge on Wednesday agreed to discharge a state gun conviction from two years ago for Jose Ines Garcia-Zarate — the man who held the pistol that killed Kate Steinle as she walked on The Embarcadero back in 2015.

Garcia Zarate’s conviction for being an ex-felon in possession of a gun is from a 2017 San Francisco Superior Court trial in which a jury found him guilty of that charge, but acquitted him of additional charges of murder, manslaughter and assault with a gun for the death of Steinle, 32, on July 1, 2015.

Garcia Zarate, an undocumented Mexican national, claimed that the shooting was an accident and that he found the gun covered in rags beneath his chair, picked it up briefly and threw it into the Bay when it fired and he realized it was a gun.

On Aug. 30, a three-judge panel of the state Court of Appeal overturned Garcia Zarate’s state gun conviction. Because the conviction was overturned, Judge Sam Feng agreed to discharge the conviction during Wednesday’s hearing.

According to District Attorney’s Office spokesman Alex Bastian, the conviction was discharged because Garcia Zarate is facing similar charges in federal court: two counts of being an ex-felon in possession of a gun.

“We make these methodically. There is a superseding indictment in this case. The federal government has charged this particular person with the same conduct that is occurring here. As a result, we’re going to step aside and let the federal government take the case,” Bastian said.

Garcia Zarate’s defense attorney, the Public Defender’s Office Chief Attorney Matt Gonzalez, was not immediately available for comment. In addition to the two counts of being an ex-felon in possession of a gun, the federal government has also indicted Garcia Zarate for being an undocumented person in possession of a gun.

Garcia Zarate, who remains in federal custody, is scheduled to go on trial on those charges in the court of U.S. District Judge Vince Chhabria in January.

-By Daniel Montes

Bay City News

Ida Mojadad is a reporter at SF Weekly, often covering politics, housing and transportation. Her words can also be found in the Orange County Register, KQED (NPR), Faribault Daily News, Northfield News and SF Examiner. You can reach her at (415)-359-2728 or by email at

Recent Posts

San Francisco Required Residents to Wear Masks During the Spanish Flu Pandemic

As the city battled the Spanish Flu, local officials passed ordinances making face-coverings mandatory.


Quarantine Thoughts: I’m Sheltering-in-Place With My New Girlfriend

Living together means mastering the dynamics of doing things together — and separately — while sharing in the same space.


Important Things to Know About Car Title Loans San Francisco

San Francisco is known to be a culturally rich and progressive city that has been highly-acclaimed as one of the…


Public Library and Chill: Online Use of SFPL Soars During Shelter-in-Place

Locals are checking out e-books and streaming movies at a furious clip, as applications for temporary digital cards top 80…


Best CBD Oil: Top 3 Brands of 2020

CBD oils are all the rage — they’re an easy way to get a high dose of active cannabidiol (CBD) into…


Without Riders, a BART Performer Scrambles to Make Ends Meet

The coronavirus killed ridership, taking away this hip-hop busker’s audience — and livelihood.