SEIU organizer Robert Haaland wasn't able to get back to us right away — he was leading a troupe of laid-off workers to offer testimonials to Newsom (ah, well, Newsom's adviser Mike Farrah). But get back to us he did, and he concurred with some of our suppositions.
In a way, the SEIU's highly public campaign was a bit like a baseball manager running on the field to argue a close play at first. There's no way that call is getting reversed. But the incident may alter the way the game is called from that point on. Getting back to politics, the SEIU convinced eight supervisors — and, ostensibly, a number of city residents — that laying off union workers is detrimental to the Healthy San Francisco program. Time will tell if the union has succeeded in planting that seed in city residents' minds. But when more layoffs come down the pike — and they will — it may give the SEIU a bit of legislative leverage.
But as for saving the current workers' jobs — this seemed to be doomed from the start. No public campaign was going to move Newsom to spend city money to save SEIU jobs.
“Maybe it was a fool's hope,” admitted Haaland. “But what else could we do? Just roll over?”